Go directly to the menu Site plan
  • Normal
  • Medium
  • Large

Les Archives de Radio-Canada

Home · For Teachers · Avalanches: Whose Responsibility?

logo_prof
Project Overview
photo
11-12
Avalanches: Whose Responsibility?
Project type: Assignment
Related topic:
Avalanche!
Subjects
Political Science
English Language Arts
Summary
Students will write a letter to the editor expressing their position about avalanche safety.
Duration
2 lessons
Purpose
To examine issues of personal and public responsibility; to express ideas, arguments, and conclusions clearly in writing
Lesson Plan
Before Exploring
Write the following statement on the board: Some people think that backcountry skiing should be limited.

Ask: What do you think? What are your rights? What are your responsibilities? What’s in the best public interest? What is a calculated risk? Can you manage your own risk?

Outline the Opportunity
Direct students to the topic Avalanche! on the CBC Digital Archives website. With a partner, have students browse the clips Don't cross 'the stupid line' and The debate over backcountry skiing , as well as the additional clips The risks of heli-skiing, The Kokanee Glacier cabin and Funding threatened. As they work, students should take notes about their opinion on back-country skiing in avalanche-prone areas.

Using the information they have gathered, students write a persuasive letter to the editor of a newspaper to express their opinion. They should state their position using the following questions as a guide.

  • What is the role of government in avalanche safety?
  • What is the role of the individual?
  • Who should pay the costs of an avalanche rescue?

    Remind students to give reasons for all of their opinions.

    Assessment Tip
    Have students trade their editorial with a partner and take turns giving constructive feedback about the letter.

  • Revisit and Reflect
    Post the letters or have students exchange letters and read them. Gather as a class and invite students to ask probing questions to the letter-writers.

    Assessment Tip
    Consider whether students wrote clearly, used a style suiting the purpose and audience, and presented a convincing argument.

    Extension
    Students can use maps to locate and record the most avalanche-prone areas in the world.